- Posts: 65
- Thank you received: 13
Automation issue: Falling edge
8 years 2 months ago #2927
by ArneiO
Automation issue: Falling edge was created by ArneiO
I have an outdoor lamp on one module that is controlled on/off by a photoresistor on an other module. I want to use the following automation conditions:
"< falling edge", fixed value 400
and
"> rising edge", fixed value 500
(Intended hysteresis to avoid lamp flickering in the transition)
But it does not work as expected:
When lamp is ON and light increases, the lamp is switched OFF (correct).
But hen lamp is OFF and light decreases, nothing happens.
If I use "<" and ">" (without rising/falling edge) instead, it works as expected, but I am not able to force the lamp on/off, as the automation takes over (which is as expected).
("<= falling edge" has the same behavior)
"< falling edge", fixed value 400
and
"> rising edge", fixed value 500
(Intended hysteresis to avoid lamp flickering in the transition)
But it does not work as expected:
When lamp is ON and light increases, the lamp is switched OFF (correct).
But hen lamp is OFF and light decreases, nothing happens.
If I use "<" and ">" (without rising/falling edge) instead, it works as expected, but I am not able to force the lamp on/off, as the automation takes over (which is as expected).
("<= falling edge" has the same behavior)
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
8 years 2 months ago #2932
by EasyIoT
I'm not sure if you can do hysteresis with falling and rising edge, because they are in two separate programs.
Replied by EasyIoT on topic Automation issue: Falling edge
ArneiO wrote: I have an outdoor lamp on one module that is controlled on/off by a photoresistor on an other module. I want to use the following automation conditions:
"< falling edge", fixed value 400
and
"> rising edge", fixed value 500
(Intended hysteresis to avoid lamp flickering in the transition)
But it does not work as expected:
When lamp is ON and light increases, the lamp is switched OFF (correct).
But hen lamp is OFF and light decreases, nothing happens.
If I use "<" and ">" (without rising/falling edge) instead, it works as expected, but I am not able to force the lamp on/off, as the automation takes over (which is as expected).
("<= falling edge" has the same behavior)
I'm not sure if you can do hysteresis with falling and rising edge, because they are in two separate programs.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
8 years 2 months ago #2933
by ArneiO
Replied by ArneiO on topic Automation issue: Falling edge
OK, never mind the hysteresis. What about what looks like a bug? Am I misunderstanding the use of falling edge / rising edge?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
8 years 2 months ago #2935
by EasyIoT
Rising edge - first time when condition is true and it was not true before
falling edge - first time when condition is not true and it was true before
Replied by EasyIoT on topic Automation issue: Falling edge
ArneiO wrote: OK, never mind the hysteresis. What about what looks like a bug? Am I misunderstanding the use of falling edge / rising edge?
Rising edge - first time when condition is true and it was not true before
falling edge - first time when condition is not true and it was true before
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
8 years 2 months ago #2937
by ArneiO
Replied by ArneiO on topic Automation issue: Falling edge
I am not sure if I fully understand your explanation.
The behavior I expect is:
"> Rising edge":
First time the parameter is larger than the given value, when it was smaller or equal before
"< falling edge":
First time the parameter is smaller than the given value, when it was larger or equal before
Does this correspond to your intended performance, or should I set the parameters differently to obtain this?
The behavior I expect is:
"> Rising edge":
First time the parameter is larger than the given value, when it was smaller or equal before
"< falling edge":
First time the parameter is smaller than the given value, when it was larger or equal before
Does this correspond to your intended performance, or should I set the parameters differently to obtain this?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
8 years 2 months ago #2939
by EasyIoT
Replied by EasyIoT on topic Automation issue: Falling edge
< and > is just condition. If you have for example temp. sensor and set email notification when temp. is > 20 then you will get email notification every time temperature is greater than 20 - usually you do not want that, because you report temperature periodically.
If you set "> rising" then you will be notified only when temp. goes from less than 20 to more than 20.
If you set "> falling" then you will be notified only when temp drops from more than 20 to less than 20.
If you set "> rising" then you will be notified only when temp. goes from less than 20 to more than 20.
If you set "> falling" then you will be notified only when temp drops from more than 20 to less than 20.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.183 seconds
Forum latest
- No posts to display.